no not saying that. Just saying that you are commenting on the clean attributes of these pups only. All fine for you but that's only a small part of it for me and probly most other guitar players. We're different is all and it's good to recognise it so we don't talk at cross purposes And the 1 trick pony reference is no more than statement of fact for anything that only does 1 thing well. Same for an SG with PAF humbuckers that only does overdrive and distortion great. They were not made to excel at clean tones and that's same for many amps also. So it helps to split up comments into clean, overdrive, distortion so it's clearer what we're talking about.