Fat P90 pickup recommendation for Neck Position in a G2420?

I've tried a few of the GFS HB pickups and like them. Not expensive. They sell a lot of other models I'd like to try.
Their HB-sized P-90 would likely bolt right in with no mods. The reviews are good and the only problem is that sometimes they are out of stock.
Keep in mind that some recommend a 380K pot with a P-90.

Welcome to Guitarfetish

 

Welcome to the forum!

Have you tried experimenting with pickup height? The Broadtron pickups on the 2420 are pretty warm to begin with, and you can warm them up by raising the body of the neck pickup and lowering the pole pieces. Might be worth a try.

 

I picked up a Guitar Madness humbucker P90 on Ebay for something like $18 to throw into a Firefly LP that I had picked up a while ago. The stock pups in the guitar were terrible (understandably), so the GM P90 was a big improvement. It definitely didn't have a boutique vibe, but it channeled a traditional P90 vibe - and it cost less than $20. I would imagine it's similar quality to the GFS pups.

I should mention that I ended up getting the ceramic 5 model, which is supposedly a little mellower than the alnico variety.

Definitely recommend if you're just looking to try something different!

 

The GFS Mean 90s are really good, I had them in an Epiphone Broadway. And yes- the "Mean" 90s, not the dream 90s. Dream 90's sound almost like strat pickups. The Mean 90's are the ones that sound like a proper P90. And they come in the right kind of mount (PAF)

https://www.guitarfetish.com/Mean-9...-Case-Our-FATTEST-Mean-90-Chrome_p_21844.html

 

It says Phat......
https://www.seymourduncan.com/single-product/phat-cat

 

The Phat Cat is a popular humbucker-sized P90.